| Champion | Defeated | Date |
| Tank (1) | N/A | 4/4/92 |
| Steven Hardy (1) | Tank | 4/12/92 |
| Tank (2) | Steven Hardy | 5/1/92 |
| Steven Hardy (2) | Tank | 5/10/92 |
| Billy The Kid (1) | Steven Hardy | 6/1/92 |
| Bobby Hardy (1) | Billy The Kid | 7/7/92 |
| Buster Brown (1) | Bobby Hardy | 8/12/92 |
| Steven Hardy (3) | Buster Brown | 9/3/92 |
| The Thunder Bird (1) | Steven Hardy | 12/25/92 |
| Steven Hardy (4) | The Thunder Bird | 1/19/93 |
| Rambo (1) | Steven Hardy | 2/14/93 |
| Steven Hardy (5) | Rambo | 3/17/93 |
| Tank (3) | Steven Hardy | 4/2/93 |
| Billy The Kid (2) | Tank | 5/22/93 |
| Steven Hardy (6) | Billy The Kid | 7/1/93 |
| The Red Blazer (1) | Steven Hardy | 8/4/93 |
| Tank (4) | The Red Blazer | 10/31/93 |
| Steven Hardy (7) | Tank | 11/14/93 |
| The Thunder Bird (2) | Steven Hardy | 12/25/93 |
| Steven Hardy (8) | The Thunder Bird | 2/14/94 |
| Billy The Kid (3) | Steven Hardy | 3/29/94 |
| Steven Hardy (9) | Billy The Kid | 4/29/94 |
| Bobby Hardy (2) | Steven Hardy | 6/12/94 |
| Steven Hardy (10) | Bobby Hardy | 6/27/94 |
| Buster Brown (2) | Steven Hardy | 7/20/94 |
| Steven Hardy (11) | Buster Brown | 8/1/94 |
| The Red Blazer (2) | Steven Hardy | 9/1/94 |
| Steven Hardy (12) | The Red Blazer | 10/31/94 |
| Steven Hardy (13) | Won title back after being stripped | 11/24/94 |
| Tank (5) | Steven Hardy | 12/25/94 |
| Steven Hardy (14) | Tank | 1/17/95 |
| Tank (6) | Steven Hardy | 2/14/95 |
| Steven Hardy (15) | Tank | 3/11/95 |
| Billy The Kid (4) | Steven Hardy | 4/14/95 |
| Steven Hardy (16) | Billy The Kid | 5/5/95 |
| The Thunder Bird (3) | Steven Hardy | 6/1/95 |
| Steven Hardy (17) | The Thunder Bird | 7/30/95 |
| The Red Blazer (3) | Steven Hardy | 8/19/95 |
| Steven Hardy (18) | The Red Blazer | 9/11/95 |
| Bobby Hardy (3) | Steven Hardy | 10/31/95 |
| Steven Hardy (19) | Bobby Hardy | 11/15/95 |
| Steven Hardy (20) | Won title back after being stripped | 12/25/95 |
| Tank (7) | Steven Hardy | 1/14/96 |
| Steven Hardy (21) | Tank | 2/14/96 |
| Billy The Kid (5) | Steven Hardy | 3/18/96 |
| Steven Hardy (22) | Billy The Kid | 4/19/96 |
| The Red Blazer (4) | Steven Hardy | 5/3/96 |
| Steven Hardy (23) | The Red Blazer | 5/17/96 |
| The Red Blazer (5) | Steven Hardy | 6/6/96 |
| Steven Hardy (24) | The Red Blazer | 7/1/96 |
| Billy The Kid (6) | Steven Hardy | 7/14/96 |
| Steven Hardy (25) | Billy The Kid | 8/1/96 |
| Billy The The Kid (7) | Steven Hardy | 8/21/96 |
| Steven Hardy (26) | Billy The Kid | 9/9/96 |