The LBYW Championship was first awarded to Steven Hardy back in August of 2008 after he defeated ATW's Nick Weston.
| Champion | Defeated | Location | Date | Match Type |
| Steven Hardy (1) | Nick Weston | Shreveport, LA | 8/28/08 | Singles Match |
| Reign (1) | Steven Hardy | |||
| Steven Hardy (2) | Reign | |||
| Jackal (1) | Steven Hardy | |||
| Steven Hardy (3) | Jackal |